
By Robert Duncan
What do you think? Can a Christian have a drink? If you believe a press release from ChristiaNet.com, touted as "the world's largest Christian portal with twelve million monthly page loads," the answer would be no.
ChristiaNet regularly sends out press releases to surveys that it runs, including a recent one on whether or not it was licit for a Christian to drink beer. The answer, according to ChristiaNet was "No".
But the answer to that poll is overtly misleading on several grounds.
First, it's an exclusive poll aimed at some Christians who have a very limited, and unique definition of what is a Christian, most likely of an evangelical flavor, which is a fairly modern interpretation of Christianity in the 2000 years of the religion's history - and would certainly rule out the majority of the world's Christians such as Catholics, Anglicans and Orthodox .
Secondly, it's a poll most definitely meant for Americans: "eighty persons who participated in the poll seemed to think it is okay for Christians to drink beer. The overall consensus with this group makes the distinction that it should be done in moderation and not to get drunk. One person made the point, 'It's acceptable unless abused or causes someone else to sin.'"
As an aside, this indeed is a new interpretation to Paul's answer of if it is okay to eat food offered to idols. Note in the original context, when Paul said it was acceptable, he was talking about food that had been offered to the idols, and the heathen priests in turn sold in the market. Paul argued that since the idols were not real nor was the god's of the heathen, then there was no real problem eating the food. Another thing was if there was a person who didn't have the formed conscience.
ChristiaNet added: "So many that answered yes also made the distinction that it should be done sensibly, perhaps in the privacy of one's home with a spouse or in the company of other mature Christians who act responsibly."
So I guess all us folks that live in Europe and like to share a bottle of wine over a meal are heathen, or at least we should do it in the privacy of our homes. Now if I could just get my favorite restaurant to bring their staff to my home to prepare the meal they way they do in their establishment.
Third, the poll size causes one to wonder about the validity of the survey. If the site really gets 12 million monthly page loads then why did only 339 people bother to respond to the survey, and then only 197 as against drinking "beer"?
"The majority of 197 out of 339 respondents felt that it isn't appropriate behavior for several reasons. One person said, 'Alcohol takes control of a person's body and does not honor God's temple.' Respondents seemed to agree overall that drinking beer, wine, liquor, or alcoholic beverages of any kind is wrong. One participant made a good point about excessive drinking contributing to car accidents and domestic violence," ChristiaNet said.
And then - just in case a person still might think there is nothing wrong with having a drink, ChristiaNet pontificates: "While an occasional drink might have some health benefits, too much can cause health problems. The risk of becoming addicted to it should be considered by those who are tempted. Each person should examine themselves and determine if they are susceptible. When intoxication takes hold it is easier to do things one wouldn't normally do and could make it much easier to sin." And this statement: "For God's children, everything in life should be measured by His word and seeking answers through prayer. God's children should not indulge in something that takes control of them but instead let Him be in control by exhibiting the Fruits of the Spirit."
One could suspect there are other reasons why ChristiaNet keeps publishing such dubious surveys and then sending out press releases - could it be that the site is seeking visitors to come to its webpage to buy the various products it advertizes?
Still, all of this reminds me of a story.
There was this businessman who had a very busy day and wasn't able to make it to lunch. On his way to boarding the plane he passed a shop in the airport that was selling various snacks, and he bought a bag of cookies - thinking that they could tide him over while on his short flight to home.
Once aboard the businessman sat down and began to read a book, and didn't really pay that much attention to what was going on around him, other than he noticed the woman who sat down next to him.
In a short matter of time, our businessman began to feel some hunger pains, so he reached down while reading his book to feel for the bag of cookies. Getting the bag, without looking up, he tore open the packaging and took out a cookie and ate it.
What to his surprise but the woman next to him without asking permission then picked up the bag and took out a cookie and ate it too!
Needless to say, he was surprised ... as I am sure that you and I would be.
Time passed and soon the businessman felt hungry again, so he reached down and took another cookie and ate it. And just as the first time, the woman followed his actions and grabbed one for herself, and ate it.
Well you can imagine the thoughts that went through the businessman's head, about how rude this person was and other things similar or worse.
To cut the story short, this pattern continued - each time the man took a cookie, then the woman would.
Finally there was only one more cookie.
Then what to the businessman's surprise the woman reached over and grabbed the last cookie, and then broke it into two, and handed him one of the halves.
To say that he was surprised at the woman's actions, if not plain rudeness, would be of no surprise. But gritting his teeth he thanked the woman with a nod of his head, and ate his half of the cookie - all the while thinking horrible things about how this woman had unjustly treated him.
In a short order the plane landed and the passengers disembarked.
On the way out of the plane, the businessman realized that he had forgotten his briefcase and so he went back to his seat. What to his surprise to discover that along with his briefcase there was also a bag that contained a whole, unopened package of cookies.
And then it dawned on him, he had unwittingly grabbed the woman's package of cookies and opened it, and it was he - not the woman - who was eating the other person's cookies.
This isn't a lesson about relativism, but when it comes to determining Christian behaviour by Sola Scriptura arguments, perhaps its best to see what has been traditionally taught and avoid overstatements.
Or in the words of my father, "just remember when pointing fingers at people that there is one pointing away, and four pointing back."
Click here to return to homepage
Post a Comment