Showing posts with label United Kingdom. Show all posts
English bishop says cohabitation cannot be equal to marriage
Friday, August 03, 2007
The president of the Committee on Marriage and the Family of the Bishops’ Conference of England and Wales, Bishop John Hine, expressed his “special concern” for a law that “would make cohabitation equivalent to marriage,” giving them “legal recognition, with their corresponding rights and titles.”
Bishop Hine said the law has to do with “financial consequences” for cohabiting couples when they separate and that it creates one set of rules for them that are completely distinct from the rules that are applies for married couples who divorce. The bishop stressed that the State “has the duty to promote, uphold and safeguard marriage as the basis of family life, the best and most stable environment for bringing up children”.
“Couples who live together and who deliberately choose not to marry neglect the responsibilities and duties of marriage, therefore, they should also be exempt from the legal benefits,” he explained.
For this reason, he emphasized, it is not acceptable to “make cohabitation equivalent to marriage” by establishing that those who have lived together for a certain length of time should receive legal recognition.
Source: CNA
Click here to return to homepage
Bishop Hine said the law has to do with “financial consequences” for cohabiting couples when they separate and that it creates one set of rules for them that are completely distinct from the rules that are applies for married couples who divorce. The bishop stressed that the State “has the duty to promote, uphold and safeguard marriage as the basis of family life, the best and most stable environment for bringing up children”.
“Couples who live together and who deliberately choose not to marry neglect the responsibilities and duties of marriage, therefore, they should also be exempt from the legal benefits,” he explained.
For this reason, he emphasized, it is not acceptable to “make cohabitation equivalent to marriage” by establishing that those who have lived together for a certain length of time should receive legal recognition.
Source: CNA
Click here to return to homepage
UK's Brown Questioned Over Pro-Protestant Constitutional Bias
Monday, July 09, 2007
By Ekklesia
New Prime Minister Gordon Brown has been challenged on the constitutional changes he is proposing by Scottish Roman Catholic Cardinal Keith O'Brien - because he has not included mention of the repeal of the Act of Settlement, which ensures that only a Protestant can take the British throne.
"I am deeply disappointed at the statement from Gordon Brown", the Cardinal, a controversial figure for his interventions on abortion and other issues, declared earlier this week.
He continued: "I remain deeply concerned that the 'Act of Settlement' will continue to exist and believe it constitutes state-sponsored sectarianism."
The Cardinal said that "I have been happy to note the recent remarks by Scotland's new First Minister, Alex Salmond that the Act of Settlement should be removed."
The Catholic Church, traditionally a bastion of Labour support, has enjoyed a surprising renewal of relations with the Scottish Nationalists (SNP), and Mr Salmond has been supportive of church schools which others - both religious and non-religious - criticise.
Cardinal O'Brien declared: "I wrote to Gordon Brown in April 2006 following comments he made on the role of the Prime Minister in the selection of Church of England bishops to say that the terms of the Act of Settlement were anachronistic and that it was 'an outstanding example of bigotry and sectarianism in the United Kingdom'. I urged him to consider these views but did not receive a reply."
When the Cardinal first wrote to Mr Brown, he was Chancellor of the Exchequer. It is traditional for the chancellor to stay out of constitutional debates.
Then PM Tony Blair, who is very sympathetic to the Catholic cause, and who is frequently reported in the media to be on the verge of converting to the Roman church, is known to be sympathetic to ending the Act of Settlement.
But his advisors were strongly of the opinion that opening up fresh constitutional questions would be unwise because he was due to leave office.
His successor, Gordon Brown, is, like Blair, a member of the Christian Socialist Movement (CSM). Brown, however, is a Presbyterian, and his father was a minister of the Church of Scotland. Neither is keen to use the word 'socialist'.
Mr Brown is known to have ecumenical sympathies, and in addition to many advisors who do not hold religious beliefs, he has been willing to listen to Chief Rabbi Jonathan Sachs, and progressive US evangelical social activist Jim Wallis.
The Act of Settlement ensured the succession to the throne by the heirs of the Protestant Electress Sophia of Hanover, a granddaughter of James I. It excludes Roman Catholics, Muslims and other non-Protestants (including humanists and non-believers) from succeeding to the throne.
From the perspective of Britain's largely unwritten constitutional arrangements, the etablished Church of England is seen as Protestant, though many of its members and theologians describe it as "both Catholic and Reformed".
The Church of Scotland (Presbyterian) has official recognition from the monarch north of the border, though it is not a formal state church.
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivs 2.0 England & Wales License. Although the views expressed in this article do not necessarily represent the views of Ekklesia, the article may reflect Ekklesia's values
Click here to return to homepage
Lessons From The UK Plot
Friday, July 06, 2007
The foiled plot in London and the attack on Glasgow Airport on the 29-30 June weekend offer several lessons and a warning for security services and terrorism analysis. Both incidents challenge some current assumptions, illustrate the difficulty of conducting terrorist operations, and may have opened a new form of aviation attack.
By John Harrison
The attacks in the United Kingdom have forced us to reexamine two assumptions and perhaps confirm an existing theory. First, it appears that all of the identified suspects were foreign nationals who had only recently arrived in the UK. This information will cause a re-examination of the idea that the threat is primarily from the host community Muslims. This assumption still has validity, but as was seen with the recent plot against the JFK airport, we have to recognize that the imported terrorist poses a major threat. And unlike the earlier trends, this group appeared to want to establish a longer operational life cycle. The fact that the attack in London was not a suicide operation may have been to allow for the attack in Glasgow.
Emerging profile
The emerging profile of the attackers is that of well-educated medical doctors. This should finally bury the notion that poverty causes terrorism. International terrorist organizations cannot conduct global operations with poor uneducated members. Insurgent groups, such as the Liberation Tigers of Tamil Eelam (LTTE) or the Abu Sayyaf Group (ASG) require large numbers, and as they draw on a large rural population, they will have a high proportion of members in poverty. The profile of the latest UK attackers does support the theory that jihadi linked groups tend to draw heavily from the hard sciences. It appears that individuals who work in areas that have a binary world view - it is either right or wrong - are more susceptible to an ideology that shares this outlook. The two attackers who have been identified are both medical doctors working in UK hospitals.
Operationally, there is much public commentary on the direct tactical links to Iraq. Sir John Stevens, former head of the Metropolitan Police and advisor on terrorism to Prime Minister Brown, has even drawn a link from Bali to Baghdad to Glasgow. One must be careful in making this leap. It is clear that the tactics of using gas as a critical component in car bombs has been seen in Iraq. As a tactic it has a rather mixed record, one that was illustrated in the plots in the UK. It is clear that the use of incendiary devices is being advanced in Iraq, but incendiaries have been widely discussed in a range of jihadi publications for years. The knowledge is widespread given that groups across the ideological spectrum have used these types of bombs.
Message for Blair or Brown?
The timing of the attack has however created much discussion, with most commentators indicating it is either a farewell statement to Blair or a welcome reception for Gordon Brown. This of course may be the case, but it is not standard practice for the jihadi community to conduct operations based on western political cycles. The two occasions that this has happened - the attack on the USS Cole and certainly Madrid - have met with mixed results. So any linkage to the change in leadership in the UK is more likely to be coincidental.
The attack in the UK does illustrate how difficult conducting a terrorist operation actually can be. The cell does appear to have been well-funded; a Mercedes is an atypical choice for a car bomb and the cell had access to middle class housing. As none of the attackers conform to existing profiles, and did not have local support, they do not appear to have attracted the attention of the security services as likely terrorist suspects. Some had been involved in activities which had drawn the attention of the security services such as protests over the Danish caricatures of the Prophet. Even with these critical advantages, the plots were not successful. The bombs appear to have been put together in a rapid fashion, with little understanding of the impact of gas fumes on the driver. The cell made no effort to conceal their members’ identities, mask their communications, or appear to have understood the security and surveillance situations in their area of operation. This is particularly odd give the fact that the cell was intending to conduct two attacks with the same members. None of this would matter of course if the cell had succeeded in the attack on Glasgow. The fact that they failed to successfully execute any of the attacks illustrates a poorly understood aspect of terrorism: they are human and are prone to all the same fallibilities facing the rest of humanity.
Far too often we are led to believe that terrorists are smarter and better skilled than the average person. They are exposed to a different skill set, and they are perhaps demonstrating a higher commitment to a cause than the average person, but they are still human. In this case they were operating in a hostile environment with no apparent local support for the cell and thus had to conceive of the plan, conduct surveillance, acquire materials, rehearse and then conduct the attack on targets more than 500 kilometers apart, relying on there own materials and knowledge. None of this is easy with local knowledge.
New tactic
There is, however, one worrying new tactic. The attack on Glasgow Airport was a new methodology. To date we have not seen many attacks on airport terminals outside of war zones, and none in the western world using a car bomb. If the plot had unfolded in the way the attackers intended, and there is some debate as to the actually possibility, the causalities could have been devastating. Imagine the impact on the industry if hundreds of passengers were killed on the ground waiting to check in. The aviation security system is designed to protect passengers while in the air. If the focus has shifted, we must face the reality that there is little that can be done to protect queuing passengers at the ticket counters or security screening points. The aviation industry may be in for some even more difficult times in the months ahead.
We need to remember that our society remains under threat. But we cannot respond to that threat if we are to remain free and open. We need to evaluate the risks and take necessary and appropriate precautions based on that assessment.
John Harrison is Manager of Terrorism Research at ICPVTR and an Assistant Professor at the S Rajaratnam School of International Studies, NTU
Reprinted with permission from RSIS. Copyright (c) 2007 S Rajaratnam School of International Studies, Nanyang Technological University, Blk S4, Level B4, Nanyang Avenue, Singapore 639798.
Click here to return to homepage
British Arabs Condemn Glasgow Attack And London Bombs
Thursday, July 05, 2007
By Ekklesia
The National Association of British Arabs (NABA) has strongly condemned the attack on Glasgow Airport and the car bombs found in London at the weekend - stressing that secular opinion as well as that of Muslims, Christians and others must be taken into account in seeking to move beyond war and terror.
Dr Ismail Jalili, who is chair of the National Association of British Arabs and past president of the British Arab Medical Association and the Iraqi Medical Association - UK, declared: "Such attacks do not serve any process for peace. Neither do they reflect the wishes of Arabs who, the world over, seek only to live in peace and who, perhaps more than most, know the despair of losing innocent family and friends as victims to such vicious attacks."
He continued: "The youth and professional status of those arrested today should demonstrate that we are now dealing with a generation that has grown up in a world dominated by injustice and a ongoing state of conflict and all that entails. This should give us cause for grave concern for those who have lost hope and the ability to ration and think clearly; who go beyond reasoning to kill themselves and other innocents as tit-for-tat measures. Revenge by killing innocent civilians is not a solution; it serves only to escalate conflict on all sides."
Dr Jalili said: "We welcome Gordon Brown’s acceptance that there must be an approach to ‘hearts and minds’ but this can only be achieved by Britain resuming its important role on the world stage as a mediator for good. We urge him to address the international issues behind terrorism."
He went on: "We also urge [the Prime Minister] and the media to review the wisdom of previous government policy which has focused on faith to the determent of secular organisations. This focus has detracted and diverted potential gains that could have been made into persuading and empowering disillusioned youth to participate via the British democratic framework."
With thanks to Helen Glibert
Click here to return to homepage
The National Association of British Arabs (NABA) has strongly condemned the attack on Glasgow Airport and the car bombs found in London at the weekend - stressing that secular opinion as well as that of Muslims, Christians and others must be taken into account in seeking to move beyond war and terror.
Dr Ismail Jalili, who is chair of the National Association of British Arabs and past president of the British Arab Medical Association and the Iraqi Medical Association - UK, declared: "Such attacks do not serve any process for peace. Neither do they reflect the wishes of Arabs who, the world over, seek only to live in peace and who, perhaps more than most, know the despair of losing innocent family and friends as victims to such vicious attacks."
He continued: "The youth and professional status of those arrested today should demonstrate that we are now dealing with a generation that has grown up in a world dominated by injustice and a ongoing state of conflict and all that entails. This should give us cause for grave concern for those who have lost hope and the ability to ration and think clearly; who go beyond reasoning to kill themselves and other innocents as tit-for-tat measures. Revenge by killing innocent civilians is not a solution; it serves only to escalate conflict on all sides."
Dr Jalili said: "We welcome Gordon Brown’s acceptance that there must be an approach to ‘hearts and minds’ but this can only be achieved by Britain resuming its important role on the world stage as a mediator for good. We urge him to address the international issues behind terrorism."
He went on: "We also urge [the Prime Minister] and the media to review the wisdom of previous government policy which has focused on faith to the determent of secular organisations. This focus has detracted and diverted potential gains that could have been made into persuading and empowering disillusioned youth to participate via the British democratic framework."
With thanks to Helen Glibert
Click here to return to homepage
Archbishop Of York Responds To Prime Minister's Statement
Thursday, July 05, 2007
The Most Revd and Rt. Hon. Dr. John Sentamu, Archbishop of York, has welcomed the announcement by the Prime Minister regarding changes to the process by which diocesan bishops are appointed.
The Archbishop of Canterbury, who is on study leave, was made aware at the outset of the Government's wish to talk to the Church about its intentions announced today.
Archbishop Williams agreed that the Archbishop of York was to deal with the matter and was briefed by Dr. Sentamu in advance of the Prime Minister's statement.
Archbishop Sentamu said: "The Prime Minister and the Secretary of State for Justice consulted me about his intentions which I believe accord with the declared wish of the Church of England.
"I welcome the prospect of the Church being the 'decisive voice in the appointment of bishops' which the General Synod called for 33 years ago (in 1974).
"I am grateful for the Prime Minister's thoughtfulness and for his overt support for the role of the Queen and the establishment by law of the Church of England which have been strongly reiterated in the Green Paper.
"The challenge we face as the Church of England is to use the sacred trust, enshrined in law, for the common good of all the people of England. Our vocation is to love God and to love our neighbours as ourselves: doing to others that which we would wish to be done to us. Our presence in every part of England must be used for bridging, bonding, partnership and friendship for all."
Following the Prime Minister's Statement and the publication of the Green Paper outlining his proposals, the Church of England will also engage in a constructive conversation with the Government concerning the appointment by the Monarch of Deans, Canons and Parish Clergy where the Sovereign has a prerogative.
The Green Paper can be downloaded from: http://www.justice.gov.uk/
Click here to return to homepage
The Appointment Of Mark Malloch Brown To Strain U.S.-British Relations
Wednesday, July 04, 2007
By Nile Gardiner, Ph.D.
The appointment of Sir Mark Malloch Brown as the U.K.'s new minister for Africa, Asia, and the United Nations is the clearest sign yet of a break with the pro-U.S. stance of the Blair government. Malloch Brown, who served as chief of staff and deputy to former U.N. Secretary-General Kofi Annan, is well known for his stridently anti-American views and fierce opposition to the war in Iraq. Although Malloch Brown will not be a full member of Gordon Brown's Cabinet, he will be entitled to attend some cabinet meetings and is expected to become one of the most powerful voices in British foreign policy after David Miliband, the newly appointed Foreign Secretary (and also a critic of the Iraq war and Tony Blair's support for Israel). His selection sends a clear signal that the Brown government will adopt a more openly critical stance toward U.S. foreign policy.
A Critic of U.S. Foreign Policy
Malloch Brown served as Kofi Annan's chief aide during the investigations into the massive U.N. Oil-for-Food scandal and played a lead role in downplaying the U.N.'s failings,[1] bringing him into conflict with the Bush Administration and leading Senators and congressmen who were pressing hard for reform of the world body. Before joining the Secretary-General's office, Malloch Brown was head of the United Nations Development Program (UNDP), a dysfunctional U.N. agency that has recently become embroiled in a series of major scandals.
As a U.N. official, Malloch Brown was an outspoken critic of American leadership on the world stage and a constant thorn in the side of the United States. He launched an unprecedented attack on Washington's approach to the U.N. in a speech in New York in June 2006, despite the fact that Washington gives over $5 billion a year to the U.N. system--more than France, Germany, China, Canada, and Russia combined. Malloch Brown warned of the "serious consequences of a decades-long tendency by U.S. Administrations of both parties to engage only fitfully with the U.N." and condemned "the prevailing practice of seeking to use the U.N. almost by stealth as a diplomatic tool while failing to stand up for it against its domestic critics."[2] He singled out for particular criticism Washington's decision to opt out of joining the disastrous new U.N. Human Rights Council, despite the fact that it was no better than the discredited former Human Rights Commission.[3]
Malloch Brown could barely disguise his contempt for the American public and media, speaking of "unchecked U.N.-bashing and stereotyping" and a "U.S. heartland [that] has been largely abandoned to its [the U.N.'s] loudest detractors, such as Rush Limbaugh and Fox News." What was needed in response, he argued, was for America's leaders to support the U.N. "not just in a whisper but in a coast to coast shout, that pushes back the critics domestically, and wins over the skeptics internationally."
The speech was also an extraordinary intervention in domestic American politics. In what can only be described as the first stump speech by an international civil servant on U.S. soil, Malloch Brown rallied his largely liberal audience[4] with these stirring words:
Back in Franklin and Eleanor Roosevelt's day, building a strong, effective U.N. that could play this kind of role was a bipartisan enterprise, with the likes of Arthur Vandenberg and John Foster Dulles joining Democrats to support the new body. Who are their successors in American politics? Who will campaign in 2008 for a new multilateral national security?[5]
Malloch Brown's remarks were rightly described by then-U.S. Ambassador to the United Nations John Bolton as "condescending and patronizing" and "a very serious affront" to the American people. Bolton called on U.N. Secretary-General Kofi Annan to repudiate his deputy's comments, which he viewed as "the worst mistake" by a U.N. official in a quarter century.[6]
Malloch Brown's intervention was symptomatic of an increasing tendency among U.N. officials to openly criticize American foreign policy. Kofi Annan had sparked a major controversy in September 2004, just weeks ahead of the U.S. presidential election, when he described the war with Iraq as an "illegal" violation of the U.N. Charter in an interview with the BBC. Annan followed these remarks with a further intervention on the Iraq issue in November 2004, when he wrote a letter to U.S., British, and Iraqi leaders appealing for Coalition forces to hold back from retaking the insurgent-held city of Fallujah.
Malloch Brown's New York speech echoed a 2005 commencement address he delivered at Pace University School of Law,[7] in which he launched a stinging attack on what he perceived to be America's lack of respect for international law. In his remarks, Malloch Brown painted the United States as an uncooperative superpower that acts outside of the rules, without respect for others:
And it's clear that abroad, President Bush's push for democracy and freedom will run aground on the shoals of American exceptionalism if the United States keeps apart from this emerging international legal system. While the U.S.'s involvement has made the World Trade Organization a powerful facilitator of free trade and global growth, elsewhere, America stands apart. The United States is the country that has opposed the International Criminal Court, the Kyoto Protocol on the environment, even UNICEF's convention on the rights of the child.
Because this great ungainly magnificent giant of a nation that has led the world in advancing freedom, democracy, and decency cannot quite accept membership of the global neighborhood association, and the principle of all neighborhoods--that it must abide by others' rules as well as its own. It certainly doesn't want to paint its picket fence the same color as the neighbors and won't turn down the dance music at a sociable hour . . . Yet respect for law, for other people's laws as a basis for building shared international law is not only a calculus of foreign policy, it is also a reflection of respect for other cultures and points of view and therefore as relevant to the United States as to others.
More recently, Malloch Brown took another swipe at Washington in a London speech, blaming the U.S.-British-led invasion of Iraq for "a loss of credibility" for humanitarian workers serving in trouble spots such as Darfur who are no longer seen as neutral: "Iraq is the immediate cause for this. And 9/11 the preceding trigger, but both come at the end of a process that has knocked humanitarian work off the straight and narrow of non-impartial help."[8]
A Barrier to Anglo-American Cooperation
Other than outspoken former International Development Secretary Clare Short, few, if any, British politicians are more disdainful of U.S. foreign policy than Mark Malloch Brown. His appointment is a slap in the face of the Anglo-American alliance and does not bode well for relations between the Brown government and the Bush Administration.
Faced with the rising threat of global terrorism, the insurgency in Iraq, counteroffensives by the Taliban in Afghanistan, and the looming threat of a nuclear-armed Iran, the next few years will be a critical time for U.S.-U.K. relations. It is imperative that London and Washington work together in addressing the major international issues of the day, which will involve close cooperation on the U.N. Security Council. It is hard to see how Malloch Brown's appointment to the British government will help to advance the special relationship.
Nile Gardiner, Ph.D., is Director of the Margaret Thatcher Center for Freedom, a division of the Kathryn and Shelby Cullom Davis Institute for International Studies, at The Heritage Foundation. Intern Joseph Cutler assisted with research for this paper.
[1] See Nile Gardiner, Ph.D., "An Assessment of the Volcker Interim Report and the Independent Inquiry Committee Into the United Nations Oil-for-Food Program," Testimony before the House Subcommittee on International Oversight and Investigations of the Committee on International Relations, February 9, 2005, at www.heritage.org/Research/InternationalOrganizations/tst020905a.cfm.
[2] Mark Malloch Brown, "Power and Superpower: Global Leadership in the 21st Century," address to the Century Foundation and Center for American Progress, June 6, 2006, at www.un.org/News/Press/docs/2006/dsgsm287.doc.htm.
[3] See Brett Schaefer and Nile Gardiner, Ph.D., "The Right Decision on the UN Human Rights Council," Heritage Foundation WebMemo No. 1031, April 6, 2006, at www.heritage.org/Research/InternationalOrganizations/wm1031.cfm.
[4] The audience included former Secretary of State Madeleine Albright and Democrat financier George Soros, who also happened to be Mark Malloch Brown's landlord. See "Losing the United Nations," The New York Sun, June 8, 2006, at www.nysun.com/article/34079.
Just weeks before his appointment to the British government, Malloch Brown was made vice president of Soros's multi-billion dollar Quantum Fund. See Benny Avni, "Ex-Deputy UN Chief Joins with Soros," The New York Sun, May 7, 2007, at www.nysun.com/article/53955.
[5] Malloch Brown, "Power and Superpower: Global Leadership in the 21st Century."
[6] U.S. Department of State, "UN Official’s Remarks a 'Grave Mistake,' U.S.'s Bolton Says," Press Release, June 7, 2006, at http://usinfo.state.gov/is/Archive/2006/Jun/08-236703.html.
[7] Mark Malloch Brown, Commencement Address to the Pace University School of Law, May 22, 2005, at http://content.undp.org/go/newsroom/may-2005/mark-malloch-browns-commencement-address-to-the-pace-university-school-of-law.en;jsessionid=axbWzt8vXD9?categoryID=593045&lang=en.
[8] Anne Penketh, "UN No Longer Seen as Neutral, Says Former Chief," The Independent, June 25, 2007, at http://news.independent.co.uk/world/politics/article2705369.ece.
Click here to return to homepage
The appointment of Sir Mark Malloch Brown as the U.K.'s new minister for Africa, Asia, and the United Nations is the clearest sign yet of a break with the pro-U.S. stance of the Blair government. Malloch Brown, who served as chief of staff and deputy to former U.N. Secretary-General Kofi Annan, is well known for his stridently anti-American views and fierce opposition to the war in Iraq. Although Malloch Brown will not be a full member of Gordon Brown's Cabinet, he will be entitled to attend some cabinet meetings and is expected to become one of the most powerful voices in British foreign policy after David Miliband, the newly appointed Foreign Secretary (and also a critic of the Iraq war and Tony Blair's support for Israel). His selection sends a clear signal that the Brown government will adopt a more openly critical stance toward U.S. foreign policy.
A Critic of U.S. Foreign Policy
Malloch Brown served as Kofi Annan's chief aide during the investigations into the massive U.N. Oil-for-Food scandal and played a lead role in downplaying the U.N.'s failings,[1] bringing him into conflict with the Bush Administration and leading Senators and congressmen who were pressing hard for reform of the world body. Before joining the Secretary-General's office, Malloch Brown was head of the United Nations Development Program (UNDP), a dysfunctional U.N. agency that has recently become embroiled in a series of major scandals.
As a U.N. official, Malloch Brown was an outspoken critic of American leadership on the world stage and a constant thorn in the side of the United States. He launched an unprecedented attack on Washington's approach to the U.N. in a speech in New York in June 2006, despite the fact that Washington gives over $5 billion a year to the U.N. system--more than France, Germany, China, Canada, and Russia combined. Malloch Brown warned of the "serious consequences of a decades-long tendency by U.S. Administrations of both parties to engage only fitfully with the U.N." and condemned "the prevailing practice of seeking to use the U.N. almost by stealth as a diplomatic tool while failing to stand up for it against its domestic critics."[2] He singled out for particular criticism Washington's decision to opt out of joining the disastrous new U.N. Human Rights Council, despite the fact that it was no better than the discredited former Human Rights Commission.[3]
Malloch Brown could barely disguise his contempt for the American public and media, speaking of "unchecked U.N.-bashing and stereotyping" and a "U.S. heartland [that] has been largely abandoned to its [the U.N.'s] loudest detractors, such as Rush Limbaugh and Fox News." What was needed in response, he argued, was for America's leaders to support the U.N. "not just in a whisper but in a coast to coast shout, that pushes back the critics domestically, and wins over the skeptics internationally."
The speech was also an extraordinary intervention in domestic American politics. In what can only be described as the first stump speech by an international civil servant on U.S. soil, Malloch Brown rallied his largely liberal audience[4] with these stirring words:
Back in Franklin and Eleanor Roosevelt's day, building a strong, effective U.N. that could play this kind of role was a bipartisan enterprise, with the likes of Arthur Vandenberg and John Foster Dulles joining Democrats to support the new body. Who are their successors in American politics? Who will campaign in 2008 for a new multilateral national security?[5]
Malloch Brown's remarks were rightly described by then-U.S. Ambassador to the United Nations John Bolton as "condescending and patronizing" and "a very serious affront" to the American people. Bolton called on U.N. Secretary-General Kofi Annan to repudiate his deputy's comments, which he viewed as "the worst mistake" by a U.N. official in a quarter century.[6]
Malloch Brown's intervention was symptomatic of an increasing tendency among U.N. officials to openly criticize American foreign policy. Kofi Annan had sparked a major controversy in September 2004, just weeks ahead of the U.S. presidential election, when he described the war with Iraq as an "illegal" violation of the U.N. Charter in an interview with the BBC. Annan followed these remarks with a further intervention on the Iraq issue in November 2004, when he wrote a letter to U.S., British, and Iraqi leaders appealing for Coalition forces to hold back from retaking the insurgent-held city of Fallujah.
Malloch Brown's New York speech echoed a 2005 commencement address he delivered at Pace University School of Law,[7] in which he launched a stinging attack on what he perceived to be America's lack of respect for international law. In his remarks, Malloch Brown painted the United States as an uncooperative superpower that acts outside of the rules, without respect for others:
And it's clear that abroad, President Bush's push for democracy and freedom will run aground on the shoals of American exceptionalism if the United States keeps apart from this emerging international legal system. While the U.S.'s involvement has made the World Trade Organization a powerful facilitator of free trade and global growth, elsewhere, America stands apart. The United States is the country that has opposed the International Criminal Court, the Kyoto Protocol on the environment, even UNICEF's convention on the rights of the child.
Because this great ungainly magnificent giant of a nation that has led the world in advancing freedom, democracy, and decency cannot quite accept membership of the global neighborhood association, and the principle of all neighborhoods--that it must abide by others' rules as well as its own. It certainly doesn't want to paint its picket fence the same color as the neighbors and won't turn down the dance music at a sociable hour . . . Yet respect for law, for other people's laws as a basis for building shared international law is not only a calculus of foreign policy, it is also a reflection of respect for other cultures and points of view and therefore as relevant to the United States as to others.
More recently, Malloch Brown took another swipe at Washington in a London speech, blaming the U.S.-British-led invasion of Iraq for "a loss of credibility" for humanitarian workers serving in trouble spots such as Darfur who are no longer seen as neutral: "Iraq is the immediate cause for this. And 9/11 the preceding trigger, but both come at the end of a process that has knocked humanitarian work off the straight and narrow of non-impartial help."[8]
A Barrier to Anglo-American Cooperation
Other than outspoken former International Development Secretary Clare Short, few, if any, British politicians are more disdainful of U.S. foreign policy than Mark Malloch Brown. His appointment is a slap in the face of the Anglo-American alliance and does not bode well for relations between the Brown government and the Bush Administration.
Faced with the rising threat of global terrorism, the insurgency in Iraq, counteroffensives by the Taliban in Afghanistan, and the looming threat of a nuclear-armed Iran, the next few years will be a critical time for U.S.-U.K. relations. It is imperative that London and Washington work together in addressing the major international issues of the day, which will involve close cooperation on the U.N. Security Council. It is hard to see how Malloch Brown's appointment to the British government will help to advance the special relationship.
Nile Gardiner, Ph.D., is Director of the Margaret Thatcher Center for Freedom, a division of the Kathryn and Shelby Cullom Davis Institute for International Studies, at The Heritage Foundation. Intern Joseph Cutler assisted with research for this paper.
[1] See Nile Gardiner, Ph.D., "An Assessment of the Volcker Interim Report and the Independent Inquiry Committee Into the United Nations Oil-for-Food Program," Testimony before the House Subcommittee on International Oversight and Investigations of the Committee on International Relations, February 9, 2005, at www.heritage.org/Research/InternationalOrganizations/tst020905a.cfm.
[2] Mark Malloch Brown, "Power and Superpower: Global Leadership in the 21st Century," address to the Century Foundation and Center for American Progress, June 6, 2006, at www.un.org/News/Press/docs/2006/dsgsm287.doc.htm.
[3] See Brett Schaefer and Nile Gardiner, Ph.D., "The Right Decision on the UN Human Rights Council," Heritage Foundation WebMemo No. 1031, April 6, 2006, at www.heritage.org/Research/InternationalOrganizations/wm1031.cfm.
[4] The audience included former Secretary of State Madeleine Albright and Democrat financier George Soros, who also happened to be Mark Malloch Brown's landlord. See "Losing the United Nations," The New York Sun, June 8, 2006, at www.nysun.com/article/34079.
Just weeks before his appointment to the British government, Malloch Brown was made vice president of Soros's multi-billion dollar Quantum Fund. See Benny Avni, "Ex-Deputy UN Chief Joins with Soros," The New York Sun, May 7, 2007, at www.nysun.com/article/53955.
[5] Malloch Brown, "Power and Superpower: Global Leadership in the 21st Century."
[6] U.S. Department of State, "UN Official’s Remarks a 'Grave Mistake,' U.S.'s Bolton Says," Press Release, June 7, 2006, at http://usinfo.state.gov/is/Archive/2006/Jun/08-236703.html.
[7] Mark Malloch Brown, Commencement Address to the Pace University School of Law, May 22, 2005, at http://content.undp.org/go/newsroom/may-2005/mark-malloch-browns-commencement-address-to-the-pace-university-school-of-law.en;jsessionid=axbWzt8vXD9?categoryID=593045&lang=en.
[8] Anne Penketh, "UN No Longer Seen as Neutral, Says Former Chief," The Independent, June 25, 2007, at http://news.independent.co.uk/world/politics/article2705369.ece.
Click here to return to homepage
Archbishop still hopeful Catholic adoption agencies can find solution in U.K.
Friday, February 02, 2007
Archbishop Vincent Nichols, Archbishop of Birmingham spoke publicly today for the first time since Tony Blair announced that Roman Catholic adoption agencies would not be exempt from a new law requiring agencies to place children with homosexual couples. The archbishop said he still holds out hope that an agreement can be reached that would keep Catholic agencies open in the United Kingdom.
The Prime Minister announced on Monday evening that there would be no exemptions to new “anti-discrimination” legislation that would grant to homosexual couples the right to seek an adopted child at any facility in the U.K. Blair granted Catholic institutions nearly two years to adapt to the new law, or face closure.
Archbishop Nichols told the Birmingham Mail today that he is hopeful that a “common sense decision,” regarding continued functioning of Catholic adoption agencies could be reached within the two year window.
"Obviously we are disappointed that the Government refused to grant to Catholic adoption agencies an amendment that would allow them to continue to serve the needs of children with good conscience,” the archbishop said. "But nevertheless, we welcome the two-year review and hope to use this time to explore any way that the Catholic agencies can secure their work in the future.”
"It gives us the opportunity to look at different practical arrangements; such as with Catholic doctors who can work with NHS clinics but it's recognized they can't play any part in abortions. I would hope that the same principle can be achieved."
Archbishop Nichols emphasized that for the time being Catholic adoption agencies remain open and continue to refer homosexual couples to other venues.
Nichols noted that while the Church is not working to ban all adoptions by homosexual couples, “there is a common sense decision that children do well with a father and a mother, and I think the majority of people would accept that.”
"I don't think for a minute that a same-sex couple would produce a gay child, but they would not be as complementary as having a mum and dad,” the archbishop added.
"What we fear is that exceptions granted under the law for same-sex couples to have the right to adopt should somehow become a new norm, a new moral law, and that, I believe, is not broadly accepted in our society.”
According to the Birmingham Mail, the Catholic Church operates seven Diocesan adoption agencies in England and Wales, including Father Hudson's in Coleshill, near Sutton Coldfield.
In an article written prior to Prime Minister Blair’s decision, the archbishop noted that in addition to the good work Catholic adoption agencies do, Catholics are also more likely to adopt children. Although Catholics only make up ten percent of the British population, Nichols pointed out, they are responsible for adopting one-quarter of the children. “Surely such a considerable proportion of adopters have a right of access to an agency that will understand, respect and support their Catholic faith and culture,” the archbishop said.
The Prime Minister announced on Monday evening that there would be no exemptions to new “anti-discrimination” legislation that would grant to homosexual couples the right to seek an adopted child at any facility in the U.K. Blair granted Catholic institutions nearly two years to adapt to the new law, or face closure.
Archbishop Nichols told the Birmingham Mail today that he is hopeful that a “common sense decision,” regarding continued functioning of Catholic adoption agencies could be reached within the two year window.
"Obviously we are disappointed that the Government refused to grant to Catholic adoption agencies an amendment that would allow them to continue to serve the needs of children with good conscience,” the archbishop said. "But nevertheless, we welcome the two-year review and hope to use this time to explore any way that the Catholic agencies can secure their work in the future.”
"It gives us the opportunity to look at different practical arrangements; such as with Catholic doctors who can work with NHS clinics but it's recognized they can't play any part in abortions. I would hope that the same principle can be achieved."
Archbishop Nichols emphasized that for the time being Catholic adoption agencies remain open and continue to refer homosexual couples to other venues.
Nichols noted that while the Church is not working to ban all adoptions by homosexual couples, “there is a common sense decision that children do well with a father and a mother, and I think the majority of people would accept that.”
"I don't think for a minute that a same-sex couple would produce a gay child, but they would not be as complementary as having a mum and dad,” the archbishop added.
"What we fear is that exceptions granted under the law for same-sex couples to have the right to adopt should somehow become a new norm, a new moral law, and that, I believe, is not broadly accepted in our society.”
According to the Birmingham Mail, the Catholic Church operates seven Diocesan adoption agencies in England and Wales, including Father Hudson's in Coleshill, near Sutton Coldfield.
In an article written prior to Prime Minister Blair’s decision, the archbishop noted that in addition to the good work Catholic adoption agencies do, Catholics are also more likely to adopt children. Although Catholics only make up ten percent of the British population, Nichols pointed out, they are responsible for adopting one-quarter of the children. “Surely such a considerable proportion of adopters have a right of access to an agency that will understand, respect and support their Catholic faith and culture,” the archbishop said.